Weekly Photo Challenge: Contrasts

Light and dark, tall and short, happy and sad — this week, share a shot that captures a contrast.

Michelle W. – The Daily Post

I wrote a Word A Week post about Contrasts a few months ago so today I thought I would take a different approach and show you a “behind the scenes” view of a few photos I took in full color but converted to black and white before sharing them here.  I liked the original scenes enough to photograph them and keep the images in my files but when it came time to post I decided the pure light and dark contrasts made for more compelling pictures.  Editing is always a matter of personal taste and while I’m happy with the black and white versions I would love to hear your comments regarding their transition from color to monotone.

Before

Contrast d

After

B&W Tuesday 12-31-13

Before

Contrast a

After

B&W Tuesday 2-11-14

Before

Contrast c

After

iPhone Monday 5-19-14

Posted as part of the Weekly Photo Challenge:  Contrasts.

Advertisements

65 thoughts on “Weekly Photo Challenge: Contrasts

  1. love the selections – all 3 have such contrast – 😉 – and the alley one is my fav – I still find myself looking deep into that scene…. and the B & W of the alley make sit seem like a different world – or just very old….. hmmm 🙂

    1. I liked how the b&w treatment highlighted the age of the alley too, Yvette. This is an old part of Seattle’s history, connected to Pike Place Market and it seemed like a good candidate for an older style of processing.

  2. In these photos, I think the color distracts from the flow of the shape lines. Your instincts are good. You moved them from nice, but ordinary, to something special.

    1. Thanks, Jim I appreciate your thoughtful comments. I try to look for images with strong lines when searching for black and white candidates and it’s nice to hear those elements have translated successfully to viewers who aren’t as close to the originals as I am.

  3. I think the alley shot is so much better in black and white. The top criss cross lines of the wire look like shafts of light at first and help to create an amazing atmosphere.
    I can’t decide about the second picture – it is just different and does work well in black and white too, but then you lose the red colour which is the highlight of the colour version. The grains in the wood show up better though.
    Again I think the third picture in black and white has an impact that the colour version lacks. You lose the distraction of the people in colour on the balcony and your eye is drawn down the line of balustrades to the light area at the end. I missed that in the colour photo.
    Gosh you would think I knew something about art wouldn’t you???

    1. Great recaps, Annette! I agree with every point and when I mentioned I like the originals too I was really referring to #2 because even though I think b&w works for it I didn’t want to give up the red. 🙂
      Lisa

  4. Nicely processed images! I think my favorite might be the shot of the street from above. The high contrast really seems to work well, and there is a lot of visual interest. Great stuff.

  5. Okay, second time this has happened to me. At first I just thought you might be in vacation but then I got curious and typed in your URL. Nope. You’ve been posting, but they haven’t been appearing in my Reader. So then I look at my Blogs I Follow list and yours is no longer listed. WTF, WordPress?? How does it just unfollow people? Now I’m paranoid about who else might have disappeared off my follow list. 😦

    1. Oh no! It’s happened to me before too… thanks so much for trying to find me. At least now I know if I disappear there is a chance for an international search party! I will be off for a few days vacation next month but will give everyone a heads up first. 🙂

      1. So flippin’ frustrating that the system can somehow unfollow people on my behalf. I am glad I figured it out juju at a few days in and not two weeks later!

      2. Me too!!! I have a love hate relationship with the reader… while it is so convenient to have everything pulled together in one place I know it doesn’t always show me posts from everyone I follow. The thought of managing who I follow through emails though is too overwhelming to think about, my inbox would explode. I do have a list of bloggers I check on if I don’t see a new post after a few days and you’re one of them. 🙂

      3. Yep, I can’t handle leaving unanswered/unread email in my inbox and when that reminder number reaches triple digits I’m a mess. It’s enough to convince me to stick with the reader. 😉

  6. Redneck Garage

    Lisa,
    I find that some photographs tell the story better in black and white. This may have something to do with the structure of our eyes. In full light we see color but when it becomes dark we see only light and dark. To take this thought to a theological level, it may also have something to do with the battle between light and darkness. In the alley scene, the black and white photograph made me believe it was night (our eye structure of cones and rods) which made me think of my safety. The color photograph shows that there was still daylight making the ally an interesting place to explore. All three of these photographs make the story more interesting.
    Patrick

    1. What interesting points, Patrick thanks for bringing up the structure of our eyes and light and dark. There are so many parallels to explore here but in the end I must say while I love bright colors I’m drawn to black and white for photography. I focus on the subject more and less on the decorative elements.

      1. Patrick Duffy

        I would agree Lisa. Black and white photography is more focused on the subject. It also takes away the difficulty in capturing the true colors due to the lighting conditions.

  7. Pingback: Happy 4th of Jul… What the HECK!!!! | rfljenksy – Practicing Simplicity

  8. Lisa, one and three are, to me, improved by going to B&W. They both look more dramatic and in the case of the first, more dangerous. However, I prefer the second in color because I think it loses something without the color. No matter; well done all around.

    janet

    1. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Janet. I like the color in the second one too and remember converting it to black and white as an experiment for one of Sally’s Monday challenges. Now I’m happy I’ve got both versions to enjoy. 🙂

  9. Hi Lisa, I hope you won’t mind but I am going to do something similar for my entry for Contrasts as I have no suitable black and white photos to use – I will credit your idea. Actually, have you thought about using this idea as a monthly meme that we can all join in. It is really interesting looking at the difference between the two photographs of the same scene and we would certainly learn a lot more about what should be taken in black and white in the first place. I love black and white photographs, but never think about taking them myself.

    1. Hi Annette, It’s great to hear you like this idea well enough to do a post along the same lines! There are a few fun blogs in this community that have weekly before and after challenges but I don’t think I’ve seen one that focuses strictly on black and white. You may be on to something. 🙂 I’ll keep it in mind for when my 1D1W project is complete in October and maybe we can start a new series for the next six months. Thanks!

  10. Pingback: Weekly Photo Challenge: Contrasts | My Aberdeen Garden

  11. I really enjoyed seeing the difference between color and black and white! You’ve inspired me to experiment a little more with my own editing options. I love the b & w because I think there’s a bit more drama, but that’s achieved because the shadows are more pronounced. Really nice. 🙂 Debra

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s